By Jeremy Watson
The Scotsman - UK
11-24-3
They are the tiny and potentially lethal guests that have taken up permanent
residence inside the body of almost every adult Briton.
A toxic cocktail of 27 chemicals is circulating in the bloodstream of the average
person, a disturbing new scientific study has proved.
The by-products of modern living - including PCBs, pesticides and even flame
retardants required by law - are endlessly circulating in the bloodstream, where
they are suspected of triggering a number of diseases including cancer.
One of the most worrying aspects of the research is that some of the contaminants
lurking inside our bodies were banned by law more than 30
years ago.
Scientists tested more than 150 volunteers aged between 22 and 80 for traces
of 77 chemicals that pollute the environment. Volunteers included Holyrood MSPs
Sarah Boyack and Christine Grahame, as well as one leading European politician.
The survey found the people they studied had between nine and 49 of the substances
- routinely sprayed on crops, added to products such as paints, and used to
protect furniture against fire - in their bodies.
None had a bloodstream totally clear of contaminants and the average figure
for the number of pollutants was 27. Readings for locations in central Scotland
were similar to those for the rest of the test sites, which included London,
Cardiff and Belfast.
Dr Gareth Thomas, who analysed the results at the department of environmental
sciences at the University of Lancaster, said: "In each of these groups
there are chemicals that might produce a higher rate of cancer. There is also
a multiplier effect that derives from being exposed to a number of chemicals."
Unborn and newborn babies were also vulnerable, Thomas said. "Children
are most at risk from this shower of chemicals when they are either gestating
or when drinking their mothers' milk. One solution will be to limit everyone's
future exposure and come up with safer alternatives."
The chemicals tested fell into three main groups in widespread use over the
past 50 years. Many were first made when manufacturers had no legal requirement
to carry out safety tests but which have subsequently been linked to several
cancers, reproductive disorders, a decline in fertility rates, birth defects
and respiratory conditions such as asthma.
PCBs were used as paint additives and as insulators in the electricity industry
and although they were banned in 1970 are still present in water and soil from
which they make their way into the food chain.
The pesticides included known hazards such as DDT. The flame retardants, known
as PDBEs, have been used extensively in textiles and plastics and in polyurethane
foam for furniture and upholstery to reduce fire risk. Tiny pieces can flake
off and be inhaled.
One of the Scottish volunteers had the highest recorded level in the country
of one type of PCB.
The tests were commissioned by the international environmental campaigning group,
WWF, to coincide with attempts by the chemicals industry to fight a tough new
testing regime for its products being introduced across Europe.
WWF, which will publish the results this week, said they provided hard evidence
of the levels of past exposure to chemicals across the country. "The industry
may say the levels found were safe but the reality is that no one knows for
sure," a spokesman said. "You can have a lag of 20 to 30 years - even
longer - before you begin to see certain effects."
He added: "We want the industry to take this issue seriously and limit
exposures for future generations."
Boyack, the former Scottish Executive environment minister, who has spent her
life living in urban areas, including Edinburgh, Glasgow, London and Stirling,
said she had agreed to be tested because there were "major public health
issues involved".
She had 26 different PCBs, seven flame retardants and four pesticides in her
blood - 37 chemicals in all. Levels of some PCBs and pesticides were well above
average.
"These tests bring chemical contamination down to a human level,"
said 42-year-old Boyack. "I was curious to know what my exposure has been.
It's a snapshot of my life so far but what I don't know is what will accumulate
over the next 20 years or at what point it becomes a danger to my health. It
all points to the need for a better testing regime."
Simon Pepper, head of WWF Scotland, who has spent the past 25 years living in
rural Perthshire, said his test revealed "worryingly high" levels
of some PCBs and pesticides.
His body contains 38 of the 77 chemicals tested for - well above the average
figure. "I am alarmed because basically it means I am a walking toxic dump,"
said Pepper, 56.
"I was not high in flame retardants but many of the younger people who
were tested were. ItÃs probably because I havenÃt bought
any new furniture recently."
Another volunteer was Margot Wallstrom, the Swedish EC Commissioner for the
Environment, who had 28 different chemicals in her blood, including traces of
all three groups.
Wallstrom is in charge of piloting through new registration, evaluation and
authorisation of chemicals (Reach) legislation throughout the EU. The aim is
to gather crucial safety information on up to 30,000 potentially hazardous chemicals
circulating in an array of everyday consumer products and subject them to a
stricter testing regime.
Environmental groups say the original proposals have already been seriously
weakened because of opposition from the chemical industry, which claims the
new regime will force up costs and lead to widespread job losses.
"Reach could bring worldwide benefits for human health and the environment.
But it looks as if the European Commission is giving too many concessions to
industry," said a WWF spokesman.
The Chemicals Industry Association, which represents the industry, said it did
not want to comment on the survey results until they were published.
On the Reach proposals, a spokesman said: "We are a heavily regulated industry
already and we want to make sure that we have regulations that work."
- jwatson [at] scotlandonsunday [dot] com
2003 Scotsman.com